• Sarah G.

    Sarah G.

    31 Sep, 2014

    I came to the store near closing time and was greeted warmly by the staff. In fact, after learning that it was my first time in the shop, I was given a sample of their famous banana pudding. After describing the variety of amazing-looking cakes, bars, and cup cakes, I decided on a mini lemon cupcake and a chocolate peanut butter bar. 5 bucks total. Both were ah-mazing! If I actually lived near this place, I would have to increase my cardio workouts. Delicious. Highly recommend!

  • Mandy L.

    Mandy L.

    1 Oct, 2015

    First, the best thing about our experience was the true hospitality of the staff. We arrived post-dinner about 9:30 and the cases were still mostly full and the team was happy to welcome us. We had three cupcakes and one piece of cake. My cupcake was the Chunky Monkey--banana cake with chocolate frosting. YES. The buttercream is the key to this delight. It's smooth, not gritty. My H had the cake, ate half, saved the rest. Moist and again, excellent buttercream. We are definitely hitting it again while we are in NYC. Do not miss this place!

  • J. M.

    J. M.

    19 Mar, 2015

    Came here on the way to get lunch haha dessert before food! Pros: - Split the carrot cupcake with my friend and it was delicious! The frosting was creamy and not overly sweet. The cupcake itself was moist and fluffy! - Great staff - they are really sweet (get it ;)) and nice - Write a Yelp review and I think you receive two small cupcakes for free? Cons: - No bathrooms - Tight space - not a lot of standing room

  • James M.

    James M.

    10 Feb, 2016

    Okay, maybe its a less fancy version on Magnolia but hands down the cupcakes and cakes taste so much better than magnolia. I can tell Buttercup uses butter and doesn't cut corners. where as other bakery who are focused on "mass production" use margarine and oil. I ordered the chunky monkey which was really a banana chocolate cupcake with chocolate buttercream icing. the icing was so smooth and rich. I am not a fan of buttercream but Buttercup changed my mind. I also ordered the caramel cupcake and again the cake was moist and the icing was amazing. The workers are very kind and attentive. Give it a try...you will love it!

  • Anna M.

    Anna M.

    21 Nov, 2016

    Obsessed with their banana pudding. Made freshly with sliced bananas and wafers that taste just like cake. In my opinion, it has a better taste than the banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery. They also have Banana pudding with layered Oreo crumbs which tasted amazing. Just ask for a sample! I wasn't too crazy about their cupcakes. The mini red velvet was a bit dry. But I'm not really a cupcake person. It's a small bakery but there is seating inside for a few couples. Chill staff, good experience.

Special Events

Birthdays

Birthdays

Our menu and store have a wide variety of custom and personalized cakes for birthday occasions

Halloween

Halloween

Our deserts also offer a menu for being certified as Glat Kosher

Weddings

Weddings

The desert menu is perfected for weddings and assorted for all event types

Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving

We offer a full service catering menu that may be personalized to your convenience

Christmas

Christmas

We offer a full service catering menu for Christmas and are all freshly baked on our premises

New Year's

New Year's

We also provide an assorted menu catered for parties and special occassions

Catering

Catering

We offer a specific assortment menu for corporate events that are all freshly baked on our premises

Office Parties

Office Parties

Our catering menu may be also customized for all party and occassions