Buttercup Bake Shop®

No, we strongly recommend not refrigerating those items. Leave them out at room temperature, preferably in an air-tight container. (Keeping them in the box is okay, too.) However, pies, puddings, and cheesecakes should definitely be refrigerated.

These items will stay fresh for about two days when left out of the fridge. (If you can wait that long to eat them!)

We have three sizes of boxes: the smallest holds 3-5 cupcakes, then 6-9 cupcakes, and our largest box holds 10-12 cupcakes. We do not individually box our cupcakes, but they fit great in our small bags.

You can order any amount, from 1 to 1,000! Just see our ordering policies page to see how much lead time we need for orders over two dozen.

Every day, we have freshly baked 7" Chocolate and Buttercup Golden layer cakes available in our case to for those last-minute special occasions. However, all of our goods are from scratch and made-to-order, so calling ahead is necessary.

While we offer a wide variety of buttercream colors, custom matching is particularly difficult with food. We are happy to work with you to find a color close or complementary in our palette to suit your needs.

We wish we could! Unfortunately, due to the delicate nature of our desserts and our commitment to quality, we are unable to ship.

While we don't do traditional tiered wedding cakes, many people choose our layer cakes as a fun, old-fashioned alternative. Cupcake wedding cakes are becoming a huge hit among our clientele, and we offer tiered cupcake trees in three sizes to accommodate weddings of all sizes. Call us for more details.

Yes, for an additional fee, we can write a letter or a word on a single cupcake. (One of our favorites is "Will you marry me?" on four cupcakes.) We can also decorate a cupcake with a simple drop flower and leaves.

Yes! We are OKS Kosher certified by Rabbi Harry Cohen, Orthodox Kasruth Supervision Services.

While very few of our items contain peanuts or peanut butter, our pans are used interchangeably. Therefore, our desserts are not suitable for people with severe allergies.

No, none of our desserts contain any artificial trans-fats.